The rationalist Mu'tazila school and other early theological movements, treated as intellectual history.
Alongside the mainstream Sunni schools, a number of theological movements emerged in the early centuries of Islam, each responding to different questions of the time. The best known is the Mu’tazila (“those who withdrew”), which arose in Basra in the second Islamic century (eighth century CE), traditionally associated with the early figure Wasil ibn Ata.
The Mu’tazila built a systematic rational theology, including the position that Allah’s attributes are identical with His essence rather than additional to it, a strong emphasis on human free will as the basis for divine justice, and — most consequential in later history — the position that the Qur’an, as Allah’s speech, was created rather than an eternal, uncreated attribute of Allah.
Under several Abbasid caliphs, most notably al-Ma’mun in the early third Islamic century, the position that the Qur’an was created was enforced by the state in an episode historians call the Mihna (“trial”), during which scholars — Ahmad ibn Hanbal being the most well known — were pressured, and in his case imprisoned, for refusing to affirm it. The Mihna was eventually abandoned, and mainstream Sunni theology settled firmly on the position that the Qur’an is uncreated. The Mu’tazila as an organised school declined over the centuries that followed and is not a living theological community within Sunni Islam today, though its arguments are still studied historically.
Other early groups are also studied historically, including the Khawarij, who held that a Muslim who commits a major sin leaves the fold of Islam, and the Murji’ah, who held in contrast that sin does not affect a person’s faith at all, deferring judgement on that question to Allah alone. Mainstream Sunni theology — across the Athari, Ash’ari and Maturidi schools — took a position between these two extremes. HikmahBridge covers these groups as intellectual history, to help explain how mainstream positions developed and were defined partly in response to them, not as live options being weighed today.
Key points
- The Mu'tazila were a rationalist theological school that arose in Basra in the 2nd Islamic century, known for positions including the createdness of the Qur'an.
- The Mihna, under Abbasid rule in the early 3rd Islamic century, was a period when the state enforced the createdness-of-the-Qur'an position; Ahmad ibn Hanbal is the most well-known scholar who refused it.
- Mainstream Sunni theology settled on the Qur'an being uncreated, and the Mu'tazila declined as an organised school — it is not a living community within Sunni Islam today.
- Other early groups, including the Khawarij and Murji'ah, are studied as part of the same history of how mainstream Sunni positions were defined, partly in response to them.
Scholarly notes
Historical claims here (dates, key figures, the Mihna) reflect standard accounts in Islamic historical scholarship. As with any history, some specific details are debated among historians; this lesson focuses on the broad, widely agreed narrative rather than disputed specifics.
Report a correction. HikmahBridge is an educational resource, not a replacement for a qualified scholar or teacher.